The human resources department is an important part of any business in the world. It acts as the backbone of your business growth, employee satisfaction, and overall workplace culture. This is why you must be very careful with HR services for recruitment, employee benefits, compliance with local labour laws, managing payroll, etc., to create a productive and legally compliant international team.
But, nowadays, one of the main challenges businesses face today is which HR model to choose – professional employer organisation (PEO) or traditional HR management. While both HR models have benefits, one of the most important factors to consider is the cost associated with PEOs and in-house HR teams.
In this blog, we will compare the cost of PEO services and traditional HR management. This will give you a clear understanding of which HR model best suits your business’s needs.
Take a look!
Understanding PEO and Traditional HR
PEO – A professional employer organisation (PEO) is a comprehensive HR solution where the PEO becomes a co-employer with your business. It helps you with a range of services, from payroll processing and employee benefits administration to risk management and compliance management. PEOs typically handle most of the routine HR functions and may also provide additional strategic services to help grow your business in a foreign country.
Traditional HR – It refers to the in-house management team that handles all HR functions of your company. The services include employee recruitment, onboarding, payroll processing, benefits administration, performance management, training, etc.
For this, you need significant resources and expertise to ensure smooth and efficient management of your company’s workforce. Also, you need to invest a lot of time to ensure everything aligns perfectly with business goals.
Cost Components of PEO Services
PEOs offer a comprehensive solution for businesses looking to streamline their HR operations, from administrative services to employee relations. But, you need to pay some price to take the help of PEOs for managing your team overseas. Here are the key cost components of PEO services:
Administrative fees
One of the primary costs associated with PEO services is the administrative fees. Often, PEOs structure this as a percentage of your total payroll or as a flat fee per employee. These fees cover complete administrative services, such as payroll and managing employee benefits. When you partner with a business payroll company or HR outsourcing company, these administrative fees ensure that the PEO operates efficiently.
Shared liability and risk management
Another key benefit of working with a PEO is shared liability and risk management. This means that the PEO helps you manage the legal and financial risks that come with being a co-employer. They share responsibility for workers’ compensation, unemployment claims, and compliance with labour laws. Therefore, by hiring a PEO, you can mitigate the risk of costly fines and lawsuits associated with expertise gaps or compliance gaps in managing employee relations.
Economies of scale in benefits procurement
With PEO, you have access to competitive rates for employee benefits. Because PEOs work with multiple businesses, they can pool resources and negotiate better rates for services like employee benefits packages and payroll services. This allows SMEs to offer all benefits to employees that are available at larger corporations, helping attract and retain talent within the budget.
The PEO operates to help businesses with economies of scale, even if you have fewer employees or less budget. For instance, if you want to run a business in Dubai without shifting there, then the best PEOs or HR outsourcing companies in Dubai can help you scale your business as they are expert in HR management in UAE.
How Does PEO Pricing Work?
Here are the different pricing models PEOs often choose for their HR services:
- Flat Fees: It is a fixed monthly fee that you need to pay to PEOs per employee. This model brings transparency and clarity, helping you understand exactly what you are paying for without any hidden costs.
- Percentage of Payroll: In this employment model, you need to pay some percentage of the total payroll to the PEO company. The percentage share can range from 2% to 15% or more, depending upon the range of services you get.
- For example, if you opt for PEO in UAE only to outsource payroll in Dubai, then your percentage will be less, and if you hire for complete PEO services, then the pay percentage will be different.
- Per-Employee Fees: Under this model, PEO sets a fee per employee per month. Again, the fee depends upon various factors such as services, quality of work, location, etc.
Factors Influencing PEO Costs
Several factors can influence the cost of a PEO:
- Company Size: Larger companies may receive volume discounts, reducing per-employee costs.
- Industry: Industries with higher regulatory requirements might incur higher costs due to the need for specialized compliance services.
- Location: Local labour laws and market conditions can impact pricing.
- Specific Services Required: Customized service packages or additional global PEO services beyond the standard offerings can increase costs.
Cost Components of In-House HR Management
Maintaining an in-house HR involves the following expenses:
Salaries
You need to pay a fixed minimum salary to in-house HR. This varies from country to country or state to state. And, if the HR is experienced, you may need to pay more considering the experience of the person. Moreover, as your business grows, these expenses can increase further, making it more difficult for SMEs to balance HR costs with other areas of their operations.
Benefits
Just like any other employee, you also need to pay benefits to HR staff such as health insurance, bonuses, retirement plans, and other perks. Paying for these benefits can add a substantial amount to the overall cost of traditional HR.
Software
To run HR operations smoothly, you need to spend money on specialized HR software for payroll processing, employee benefits administration, and compliance tracking. For client companies that need to handle large volumes of employee data, the right HR software is essential. These tools can be costly, with annual licenses and maintenance fees.
Training expenses
To keep your in-house HR staff up to date, you need to spend on training and development programs. The need for specialized training in areas like employment laws or workforce analytics may also necessitate external service provider involvement, which adds to overall HR management costs.
Furthermore, the costs associated with employee turnover can also add up. If an HR team member leaves, the process of recruiting and training a replacement creates additional financial strain.
Compliance and legal costs
Human resources compliance is a critical area that many businesses overlook until it’s too late. A major cost that comes with maintaining an in-house HR department is the risk of compliance issues. Staying up to date with employment laws and managing business compliance can be complex and time-consuming. Without proper management, businesses risk facing legal penalties or fines.
Maintaining an in-house HR team might seem like a cost-effective solution at first, but it can quickly become expensive when you factor in the full scope of the responsibilities involved. The key consideration here is not just employee management but the many hidden costs that arise in areas like payroll processing, employee benefits administration, and compliance management.
Comparative Analysis of PEO Services and Traditional HR Management
It’s essential to compare the cost of each model to determine the best option for your business. Here is a comparative analysis of both PEO services and In-house HR:
Direct Cost
PEO services discuss charges for their services in advance with you. This means there are no hidden costs associated with PEOs’ payroll services, employee benefits administration, and more. This helps you avoid any additional costs for managing complex HR tasks.
On the other hand, for in-house HR management, you need to set a budget for hiring and maintaining an HR team every month. In addition, you will need to pay for salaries, office space, technology, and other employee benefits.
You may feel upfront costs for PEOs is high, but it is cost effective as there is no overhead cost associated with them.
Indirect Cost
With PEOs, there are no indirect costs. But when you work with an in-house HR team, there are many indirect costs that you need to pay from time to time. For instance, health coverage, system service, updating software, training, legal conflict, electricity bills, and more.
While big companies may bear these costs easily, small to medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) must consider them as they can affect your growth and productivity.
Here is a tabular comparison between the costs of PEOs and in-house HR:
| Category | PEO services | Traditional HR management |
| Cost structure | Fixed monthly fee per employee or percentage of payroll. | Salaries, bonuses, training costs, software updates, etc. |
| Upfront costs | High upfront costs but no hidden charges. | Low upfront costs but regular hidden charges to pay for Hiring, onboarding, training, etc. |
| Staff costs | Included in the upfront service fee cost. | Monthly salaries for HR managers, specialists, and the whole team. Plus bonuses. |
| Compliance costs | Covered by PEO company.
|
High internal compliance costs, with legal and consultant fees to ensure adherence. |
| Recruitment costs | Almost none | High |
| Additional costs | No additional cost; everything is transparent and clear in starting the relationship. | It has additional costs like utility bills, system expenses, employee turnover costs, etc. |
Services Comparison – PEOs Vs. In House HR
Here is the tabular comparison between the services provided by PEOs and in-house HR:
| Services | PEO | In-house HR |
| Recruitment and hiring | Assist with recruitment tools and strategies. Do background checks. | Handles complete recruitment job, onboarding process, and offboarding. |
| Employer relationship | Shared responsibilities, reducing administrative burden | All responsibility is on your team and you are responsible for all HR operations and legal liabilities. |
| Employee benefits | Offers access to competitive employee benefits packages at discounted rates. | Manages employee benefits. But, the in-house team has limited options for insurance and other benefits at higher costs. |
| Payroll management | PEO manages payroll processing and ensures compliance with payroll laws. | In-house HR manages payroll and filings using internal resources. Sometimes, they may lack compliance with local laws when managing a team overseas. |
| Compliance support | PEO ensures compliance with local labour laws and regulations. | In-house HR is responsible for staying updated on the latest local labour laws. |
Which Option Is Best for Your Business?
Both PEOs and traditional HR management have their pros and cons. You need to find out your business needs, budget, and goals to choose the right HR model. If you are a start-up or SME that wants to expand globally, then selecting a PEO to manage HR functions is a great option. On the other hand, for well-established and larger organizations, having an in-house HR team can be beneficial. But, you can also opt for co-employment with PEO to avail of benefits.
PEOs: The Budget-Friendly Option for Many
PEOs are often considered the cost-effective solution for businesses that focus on affordability and simplicity. By leveraging the expertise of PEO professionals and economies of scale, you are able to reduce administrative burdens and operational costs. This is especially true for startups and SMEs that find managing HR complex.
By working with PEO, you can relieve yourself of human resources, payroll, and capital management tasks, which can make your management more productive. This allows you more time to focus on core business issues, including marketing. It can also create a happy environment for your employees due to the better benefits you can offer to them.
Your Go-To PEO Partner In The UAE
Partnering with Connect Resources, a trusted and reliable Professional Employer Organization (PEO) in Dubai, can significantly improve your business. With many years of experience in the industry, we have the necessary expertise and technology to handle all your HR needs, from talent recruitment and management to payroll, benefits, HR, and risk management.
All our comprehensive PEO services in the UAE suite are specially designed to address key challenges such as navigating local labour laws and regulations, including compliance management, visa sponsorship, recruitment and payroll services. Reach out today to discover how we can optimise your HR processes!
Final Words
Now, you know the differences between PEOs and traditional management, so choose the right option based on your needs and budget. Also, consider the services offered by both and check which is beneficial for your business growth in a foreign land. If you find your business is lacking HR expertise or not compliance with local laws, then choosing a trusted PEO is the best option for you and your business.
